COMMON
MISCONCEPTIONS ABOUT WOMAN ABUSE
Myths
and stereotypes about woman abuse often isolate abused women and
prevent them from accessing and receiving appropriate services.
MISCONCEPTION:
Is woman abuse a private family matter?
FACT:Woman
abuse is not a private family matter. Woman abuse is a widespread
societal problem that has devastating effects for individual
victims, their children and their communities (National Clearinghouse
on Family Violence). Further, some of the tactics of woman abuse
including physical and sexual abuse, threats, harassment, and
stalking are criminal offences and therefore not a private matter.
Keeping woman abuse private only serves to support the perpetrator
of abuse and does not protect the women and children who are
subjected to it.
MISCONCEPTION:
Is woman abuse a new problem?
FACT:
Woman abuse is a chosen act against a chosen victim. The
abuser intends to seek compliance from or control over the victim.
It is an act which has been condoned by society for centuries.
In 18th century England, laws gave husbands the right to "discipline"
their wives. One law, the Rule of Thumb, gave men the right
to whip their wives with a switch no thicker than their thumb.
Also, until 1965, in Canada, a husband would not be charged
with assaulting his partner unless the woman could prove sufficient
bodily harm (Dobash and Dobash, 1979). Moreover, it was not
until 1985 that a man could be charged with sexually assaulting
his wife. The historical unequal power relations between men
and women have led to domination over and discrimination against
women by men.
MISCONCEPTION:
Does woman abuse only happen to poor or uneducated women?
FACT:
Women from all ages, socioeconomic, ethnic, cultural, educational,
occupational and religious groups are abused. Perpetrators of
woman abuse can be found in all age, cultural, socioeconomic,
educational occupational and religious groups.
MISCONCEPTION:
Is woman abuse a rare occurrence inflicted upon only a few women?
FACT:
Woman abuse is often referred to as an epidemic in our society.
In 1993, Statistics Canada found that 3 in 10 married or common-law
women reported experiencing abuse where criminal charges were
warranted. These statistics do not include women in dating relationships
and non-criminal behaviour such as emotional abuse or using
isolation. Between 1974 and 1993, the number of Canadian women
murdered by their partners has been approximately 78 women per
year.
MISCONCEPTION:
Is a "Domestic Dispute" a dispute/argument which has
gone too far?
FACT:
Woman abuse is not a dispute which has become out of hand. It
is the intentional action of one individual to gain and maintain
power and control over another. It is about gaining control
over and individual, not losing one's control. Abusers are making
choices about their actions even when they are claiming that
they "lost it" or were "out of control."
Many women at LAWC report that if the abuser gets angry in the
grocery store, the abusive partner waits until they are home
before abusing her. Also, women report that when the abusive
partner smashes things in the home, it is usually something
belonging to her, rather than the abuser. These are two examples
that show the intentionality and decision making of abuse and
not the escalation of anger and out of control behaviour.
MISCONCEPTION:
Can an incident of woman abuse be a minor, isolated incident?
FACT:
Woman abuse is rarely an isolated incident but rather a repeated
pattern of tactics used to gain and maintain power and control
over a woman. Woman abuse includes a wide range of coercive
tactics that can include physical, sexual and emotional abuse
as well as threats, intimidation, and use of the children. Abused
women report that often the tactics of control increase in severity
over time. Woman abuse causes serious and sometimes permanent
injuries including death. Emotional abuse can also be as debilitating
as physical abuse and as psychologically damaging as other types
of abuse (World Bank, 1996).
MISCONCEPTION:
Do women provoke abuse in most cases?
FACT:
No one deserves to be abused. Provocation is an excuse that
places responsibility and blame for violence on the victim rather
than on the perpetrator. This misconception fails to hold abusers
responsible and accountable for their own actions. It also clearly
fails to protect the victim. LAWC clients identify that they
often deliberately alter their own behaviours, choices or decisions,
in order to avoid negative reprisals from their abusive partners.
MISCONCEPTION:
Are abusers sick or mentally ill?
FACT:
Woman abuse is too widespread to be explained by mental
illness. It is a learned behaviour that is intentional. It is
also observed and reinforced in society. Woman abuse is not
caused by genetics or illness (Bandura, 1973; Dutton, 1988).
The socially sanctioned belief that men have the right to control
women in relationships and the right to use force to ensure
that control is reinforced by society's major institutions such
as, social, legal, religious, educational, mental health, medical,
entertainment/media, and the family (Ganely 1989).
MISCONCEPTION: Do drugs or alcohol cause abuse?
FACT:
While it is sometimes true that abusers may be under the influence
of drugs or alcohol during abusive incidents and that these
substances may contribute to the severity of the abuse, drugs
and alcohol do not cause the abuse (Rodgers, 1994). Abused women
often say that their partner's are also abusive when sober.
Stopping the substance abuse will not end the violence. Both
issues must be addressed.
MISCONCEPTION:
Is woman abuse really spousal abuse? Both partners can be abusive.
FACT:
Some people suggest that woman abuse is really spousal abuse
because both parties have been abusive. Careful assessment must
be undertaken in these situations to determine who is the primary
aggressor and who is the victim. Often this assessment will
reveal that one person starts the violence while the victim's
violence is used in self-defence. To help assess this situation,
two good questions to ask are: "Who is afraid of the other?"
And "Who changes their behaviour for fear of negative reprisals?"
MISCONCEPTION:
Does witnessing woman abuse harm children?
FACT:
Yes. Studies have shown that children often experience symptoms
associated with witnessing woman abuse such as nightmares, flashbacks,
anxiety and fear. Children who witness or who are exposed to
woman abuse are also at greater risk for behavioural problems
such as outbursts of anger and aggression and conflict with
the law. In fact, the level of emotional and behavioural problems
found in children who witness or are exposed to woman abuse
is similar to that of children who are themselves directly physically
abused (Hughes, 1988; Jaffe et al, 1985).
MISCONCEPTION:
Do women stay because they like the abuse?